Who We Are

After more than 50 years of service, The Starr Group has grown into one of Milwaukee’s largest independent insurance agencies. Servicing Southeastern WI, The Starr Group is unique in their approach to client services because of the high education requirements for their sales and service personnel. The goal is to not only provide insurance to clients but also to become an adviser who reviews clients' needs and analyzes their total cost of risk. Having a staff that is highly educated in the industry promotes higher quality advice and insurance products for clients.

Our Philosophy

Our vision is to lead in the creation and delivery of risk reducing services and insurance programs for our clients, improving their Total Risk Wellness. 

Driven by our vision, values and strategies, The Starr Group Mission is to provide a  positive and empowering work environment for our employees and to be a beacon of innovation and integrity to our clients.

We firmly believe that if we build a team of character we will not only accomplish, but exceed, our goals.

I-PREACH Values:

Integrity - That which we profess in public is the same as what we do in private. Integrity is a constant reference point to keep us intact and uncorrupted. It means holding steadfast to our commitments and not just our desires. Integrity is firmly adhering to our moral values.

Passion - We foster an environment that brings limitless energy and meaning to work along with an opportunity to achieve confidence and full potential. Passion fuels our drive allowing energetic pursuit of our goals. Our passion is our purpose. 

Respect - Respect is showing consideration and appreciation. IIt means respecting our teammates and our clients as individuals; trusting them, supporting them and enabling them to achieve their goals in both their professional and personal lives. 

Excellence - We foster an environment that is driven to excel. Excellence demands that we think beyond our dreams; it challenges the heart, encourages the soul, and excites the mind.

Acknowledgement - We will show appreciation and gratitude for our collegues, our customers and our own accomplishments, celebrating excellence as it is achieved. 

Communication -To actively listen and respond to information we receive and use it to improve our relationships, services and solutions. 

Health & Wellness - Employee and Customer Wellbeing are the foundation of our Corporate Wellbeing. We strive to educate, motivate and empower our employees to take control of their own health and wellness. 



5005 W Loomis Rd
Greenfield WI, 53220

Recent Tweets

Social Media

Employee Testimonials

Meet The Starr Group Service Teams

What do you like best about being a Starr Group employee? (Taken from 2015 Marsh Berry Confidential Employee Survey)

  • The work-life balance and the way they show they truly care for their employee’s health and well-being.
  • The Starr Group provides the support and tools that allow me to provide the best possible service to our insureds.  And the flexibility allows a true balance of work and home life.
  • I really like the camaraderie of the company as a whole.  Everyone here is held to high ethical standards.  We work well as a team.  I appreciate the work/family balance. There’s no micromanaging.  And employees are recognized on a regular basis for great performance.  I never realized what my dream job was until becoming a part of The Starr Group!
  • Everything.  The job is challenging, the customers and my co-workers. Everyone here is so helpful and there is such a positive attitude.
  • The belief that everyone contributes his or her own talents to make Starr Group the best agency to work for.  Management treats all employees as equal and are available to discuss any matter without retaliation.  They have instituted and Employee Advocate this year to any employee that feels they cannot talk to management regarding a problem.
  • Feels like Family.  They care a lot!
  • One of the most rewarding things about being a Starr Group employee is knowing that our faithful leaders, Tim and Mary, want us to succeed not only for the agency’s reputation, but more importantly for our own professional journey.  They hand us the tools to be successful, and fully know that they can count on their employees to thrive.  It’s wonderful working for an organization that trusts in their employees in this way.
  • The family environment.  Everyone here is on the same team and we all work together to exceed.  I am extremely grateful to be part of The Starr Group.  I love my job and the people I work with.
  • I love how positive the atmosphere is.  You can’t avoid negativity, but positivity is what’s enforced.
  • Employee well-being and profitability go hand in hand.
  • The culture, people working hard in a positive environment.  The leadership, always being innovative, striving to reach goals that are communicated.
  • The integrity of this organization allows me to be fully confident in the products and service when selling.

News & Press

Starr Newsroom


Better Business Bureau A+ Rating

BBB Torch Awards (Video)  Torch Award Winner

Healthiest Employer in SE Wisconsin  2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015

Healthiest 100 Workplaces in America 2014, 2015

Platinum FIt-Friendly Award Winner 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015

Best Places to Work Winner, 2015

Best Insurance Agency to Work for in the Midwest, 2015

WELCOA Well Workplace Award Winner 2011, 2014

A Wisconsin Best Practices Agency since 2001 and a national Best Practices Agency since 2004. "Best Practices" is an elite group of insurance agencies recognized for their operational excellence. We were chosen to be a Best Practices Agency based upon maintaining outstanding performance benchmarks in the areas of customer service, growth, stability and financial management.

More Starr Accolades


The following activities and amenities are available to employees to support their health and wellness:

  • Nutritional advice
    • Lunch and Learns
    • Cooking classes
    • Weekly Emails with health tips and recipes
  • Nutritious on-site food choices
    • Salad Wednesday (weekly)
    • Smoothie/Parfait Tuesdays (first Tuesday of every month)
  • Wellness challenges and education programs
    • One on One Wellness Coaching with a dedicated Starr Group RN
    • No Excuses - twice monthly well being and weight loss support group
    • Maintain Don't Gain Challenges
    • Tobacco cessation coaching available
    • Fitness Trainer on site six times a year and available for one on one coaching 
    • Massage Therapist (monthly chair massages on site on company time, free once per year)
    • Introduction to Yoga
    • Acupuncture and Ayurveda coaching
    • Office Olympics
    • Iron Man in a Month Challenge
    • Spring and Fall Step Challenge
    • Pedometers provided for all employees
  • Stress Reduction
    • Lunch and Learns providing stress management techniques
    • Stomp Out Stress sessions - 10 minutes "nature" relaxation
    • Flash Fitness - light aerobic "recess"
    • Stress reduction challenges
  • Filtered water and ice available
  • Biking or hiking trails nearby (hiking trails ideal for walking meetings)
  • Voluntary health testing (biometrics, health risks, nurse review-completed annually)
  • Spouses, significant others, and family members are eligible and encouraged to participate in all wellness activities
  • Access to natural ambient light

The Starr Group offers employees who are parents the following amenities and programs to help make their lives a little easier:

  • Private space for nursing mothers

The following programs and areas are available for employees to meet and eat their meals:

  • Kitchen
  • Stone Creek Coffee served
  • Essential Oil Diffuser available to relax thru lunch
  • Large flat screen T.V.
  • Catered lunches for specific company meetings/events
  • Smoothie/Parfaits Tuesdays once a month
  • Salad Wednesdays weekly

The workspace at The Starr Group offers the following amenities for employees;

  • One Walking Workstation available for all employees to use during or outside of work hours
  • Everyone has the option for: dual monitors, cordless headsets, ball chairs
  • Private work spaces
  • Central spaces for employees to gather, work, or relax
  • Intra-office communication technology (beyond email) Instant Messaging
  • Private restrooms
  • Ability to decorate personal work space
  • Most work spaces have access to natural light

The Starr Group offices provide a fun environment for employees:

  • Suburban location(s)
  • Nearby shopping
  • Nearby yoga or athletic/fitness clubs
  • Variety of establishments nearby to socialize
  • Nearby walking or biking trails
  • Convenient public transportation
  • Places to relax, eat, or work outside
  • Publicly offered day care facilities
  • Publicly offered pet day care facilities
  • Farmers market
  • Financial institutions

The Starr Group offers areas where employees can have fun and play games. These include:

  • Quiet rooms to relax/destress
  • The employee run Fun Committee coordinates two fun indoor or outdoor activities per month including (not limited to) pictionary, ping pong, and/or various lawn game competitions.
  • Intranet on-line library including wellness information, industry information, and recipes
  • The Starr Group has three employee run committees:
    • Fun-Vision is to create an environment that is rich in fun and passion so daily activities are fueled with limitless energy.
    • Best of the Best/Ethics-Vision is to continually work together to create and maintain an environment that enables each of us to reach our full potential by providing a balance between our personal and our professional lives. We are committed to promoting an environment that goes above and beyond ordinary business practices and ethics.
    • Wellness-Vision is to promote an environment that encourages and supports proper nutrition, regular exercise and on-going lifestyle management in order to achieve an overall increase in energy, a reduction in stress, a more positive outlook on life and an increase in total body wellness; thereby improving employee achievement, productivity and morale along with a healthier lifestyle.

The Starr Group offers the following employee community building activities:

  • Company-wide employee social activities include:
    • Annual Family Summer Picnic and Winter Christmas Party including spouses and significant others
    • Holiday Breakfasts
    • Chili Cook-off Competition
    • Team Summer Cookout Contests
    • Opening Day Cookouts
    • Costume Contests
    • Halloween Pumpkin Decorating Competition
    • Gingerbread Boy Decoration Competition
    • A twist on Secret Santa -- employees select co-worker’s name to give a toy they would like -- then employees donate the toy to Toys for Tots
    • Annual Awards Banquet where employees are acknowledged and awarded for meeting wellness and sales goals. Medals, cash prizes and Wellness PTO Days are awarded.
  • Volunteer events 
    • Special Olympics of WI
    • Participation at Special Olympic sports activities
    • Special Olympics Polar Plunge Corporate Sponsor and Annual Plunge Team
    • Food, school supply, and toy drives
    • Milwaukee Heart Walk
    • Team Melanoma Run at the Zoo
    • Employee chosen charities are sponsored on a quarterly basis
  • Birthday recognition
  • Work anniversary recognition
  • Goal achievement celebrations
  • Company blood drive
  • Sports team sponsorship
  • Shared special events/sports tickets
  • Local sports team tickets shared with employees: Milwaukee Bucks and Brewer ticket lotteries
  • State Fair and Summerfest tickets for all employees
  • Book Club monthly

The Starr Group offers the following services that help employees with day-to-day non-work needs:

  • On-site dry cleaning Pick-up and Drop-off
  • Food Coop ordering and delivery on-site

The following eco-conscious options are available to employees at The Starr Group:

  • Bike parking
  • Access to public transportation (Loomis/Southridge Flyer)

 Employees have the option to participate in the following:

  • Personal music choices (headphones, radio, CDs) 
  • Dress code - Business, Casual Fridays and Casual fun days
  • Fridays the office closes at 4pm
  • Pre-holiday half days
  • Access to personal social media 
  • Walking / outdoor meetings
  • Discounts on company products
  • Company coordinated discount program with partner companies
    • Employee discounts for Y and WAC membership
  • Performance contests with prizes
  • Free parking
  • Formal or informal contests

Extreme Perks

At The Starr Group, employees are eligible for health and welfare insurance benefits after the first of the month following 60 days.

The Starr Group pays 75% of premiums for individual health insurance plans for eligible employees.

The Starr Group offers part-time or flex-time employees full time health care benefits to employees that work less that 30 hours per week.

The Starr Group's 401(k) program is available to employees after one year of employment and the company provides an average of a 3% contribution to all participants 

The following benefits are available to full-time employees at The Starr Group:

  • Dental insurance
  • Vision insurance
  • Short-term disability
  • Long-term disability
  • Flexible Spending Account
  • Health Insurance Spending Account
  • Company contributions to Flexible or Health Insurance Spending Account
  • Life insurance
  • Life insurance for employee's family
  • Employee Assistance Program
  • Voluntary critical illness and accident plans
  • Pre-paid legal

The Starr Group offers 25 days of paid time-off (including vacation days, sick days, personal days, holidays) annually for new employees.

The following creative time-off opportunities are available:

  • Flexible work hours 
  • Job sharing
  • Paid time-off to volunteer
  • Unpaid time-off to volunteer 
  • Visit the Flextime Culture Badge to learn more about work flexibility offered by The Starr Group
  • Pre-holiday half days
  • Friday – the office closes are 4pm

The following incentives and programs are available to employees:

  • Subsidized fitness club membership
  • Availability of fitness or weight-loss coaching programs 
  • Subsidized fitness or weight-loss coaching programs 
  • Company product discounts for employees
  • Discounts for other services and products for employees
  • Profit sharing
  • Personal finance assistance coaching
  • Recognition of a new family addition (aka “baby cash”)
  • Flu shots
  • Please visit the Fun Culture Badge to learn more about the robust wellness programs The Starr Group offers employees

At The Starr Group, employees have the opportunity to own part of the company.

  • Producers whose sales exceed $500K have the opportunity to buy company stock 

Corporate Responsibility

The Starr Group is committed to the following:

  • Improvement of community social needs and practices
  • Triple bottom line (people, planet, profit)
  • Care and development of employees
  • Fiscal responsibility
  • Human rights
  • Values, ethics, and integrity
  • Inclusion and diversity
  • Green practices

The Starr Group believes in transparency and disclosure and holds 2 mandatory All Agency employee meetings per year; and distributes quarterly newsletters for employees and customers.

The Starr Group’s commitment applies to all business operations and locations. Learn more about The Starr Group's Vision and Values here.

The Starr Group measures their commitment to mission, vision and values in the following ways:

  • Quantifiable goals are documented
  • Goals are clearly described to employees
  • Activities that achieve goals are documented
  • Employees are trained on goals, activities and results measurement
  • Year-over-year results are measured
  • Year-over-year results are published
  • Third party validation is utilized to measure results
  • Board of Directors or other governing body reviews goals and results
  • Employee Performance Management program measures employee attention and performance related to goals and results
  • Screening processes that review material and product purchasing decisions based on suppliers’ commitment to socially responsible efforts

All new employees receive an email each day for 7 weeks expounding on the company's values.

Employees are required to read How Full is Your Bucket and complete Strength Finder as well as follow through with acknowledgement of others (as part of core values - I-PREACH).

The Starr Group has a clearly defined human rights policy regarding the protection of: 

  • Minority groups
  • Women's rights
  • Workers' rights
  • Child labor

 The Starr Group’s services have a direct positive contribution to your company's commitment to socially responsible efforts in the following ways:

  • Products and services contribute to improving health
  • Products and services contribute to improving community efforts (literacy, arts, charitable organizations)
  • Products and services help rebuild our local community
  • Products and services contribute to improving social and economic inequality

A percentage of sales commissions are donated to trade organizations (NARI and BHIC)

Customers of a certain size are eligible for: safety, defensive driver training, HR and executive coaching/training.

The Starr Group has a full-time position dedicated to monitoring our mission, values, or ethics statement and the execution of its commitment. Best of the Best is The Starr Group’s employee-run committee with a dedicated employee liaison to monitor values execution within the office.

The Starr Group provides at least a living wage for all of their employees by setting the lowest paid wage at $12.00 per hour

The following documents are available to all employees:

  • Employee handbook
  • Inclusion or discrimination policy
  • Harassment policy
  • Description of how the performance management plan works
  • Description of how to apply for open positions in the company
  • Intranet with a personnel guide, articles, calendar of events, photos, and benefits overview.

The Starr Group has a published process for employees to ask questions, give feedback or complain without negative consequences and offer suggestions or innovations.

The Starr Group surveys employees regarding their satisfaction and engagement on an annual basis.

The Starr Group has a variety of ways they support the community:

  • 1-10% of sales or profits for donation to multiple charities.
  • The Starr Group allows employees 8 hours/year to volunteer during work hours.
  • The Starr Group has a "Charity Kitty" into which $5 donations are made by the company when employees are complimented by a customer or vendor for their work or service. At the end of the year, the total is doubled and contributed to The Boys and Girls Club of Milwaukee.
  • Casual Day for a Cause - employees pay $2 to dress casually on Friday and all funds collected for a quarter are donated to an employee-chosen
  • Employee committees determine all or part of the company's time, talent, and financial contributions.
  • Learn more about other Community and Philanthropic activities here.

The Starr Group is aligned with the following community groups:

  • Big Brothers Big Sisters
  • American Heart Association
  • Special Olympics of WI
  • Boys and Girls Club of Milwaukee
  • Toys For Tots
  • Hope House
  • The Starr Group "adopts a family" during the holidays

The Starr Group has a written customer guarantee, customer warranty or protection policy and has a published process for customers to ask questions, give feedback, or complain including:

  • BBB
  • Feedback links on website via the Contact Directory, and various other social media
  • Live Chat Now online service

The Starr Group monitors customer satisfaction in the following ways:

  • We have a written methodology to survey customers
  • We survey customers annually for their level of satisfaction and input
  • Current results are shared with the public
  • Current results are shared with employees
  • Processes and operations are adjusted based on customer feedback
  • Each claim is provided with a satisfaction survey

The Starr Group is proud of the recognition and awards they have received from the insurance industry and other notable awards programs.  Click here to learn more about The Starr Group's Accolades.



The following scheduling options are available to salaried employees:

  • Choose the beginning and end hours (8am-5pm or 7am-4pm) on a case-by-case basis
  • Allow salaried employees to work a part-time schedule on a case-by-case basis
  • Choose the number of hours in a day (Five 8-hour days or Four 10-hour days) on a case-by-case basis
  • Work a reduced schedule during a certain time of the year
  • Job share (two part-time employees share one full-time position) on a case-by-case basis
  • Change from full-time to part-time while remaining in the same position or level on a case-by-case basis
  • Work from home occasionally on a case-by-case basis
  • Resources are provide to remote employees
  • Work from an alternative location to accommodate a family need

The following scheduling options are available to hourly employees:

  • Choose the beginning and end hours (8am-5pm or 7am-4pm)
  • Choose the number of hours in a day (Five 8-hour days or Four 10-hour days)
  • Job share (two part-time employees share one full-time position) on a case-by-case basis
  • Change from full-time to part-time while remaining in the same position or level on a case-by-case basis
  • Choose when they take breaks
  • Choose when they take meal breaks
  • Take time off during the workday to attend to important family or personal needs without losing pay
  • Control the amount of overtime they work
  • Work a guaranteed minimum number of hours per week

On average, hourly employees know their regular work schedule 4+ weeks in advance.

The following technologies are offered to employees to facilitate flexibility in the workplace:

  • Company subsidized smartphone usage (Sales, claims and IT department employees) 
  • Video conferencing 
  • Remote access to organizational computer system
  • Company provided laptops/tablet computers

The Starr Group provides 8 hours paid per year for employees to volunteer.

The Starr Group offers the following paid time-off (PTO) options for employees:

  • Use of sick time for personal time or ill dependents
  • Carry over unused sick/personal/vacation time to future years(s)
  • Take an extended career break for care giving or other family responsibilities on a case-by-case basis
  • Unused vacation time can be carried over to future year(s)
  • Bereavement time off for the passing of their family or partner
  • Time off during the workday to attend to important family or personal needs

Best of the Best Committee dedicated to promoting a better balance between personal and professional lives of employees.



Our Vision is to lead in the creation and delivery of risk Reducing Services and Insurance Programs for our clients, producing a measureable improvement in their Total Risk Wellness.

Driven by our vision, values and strategies, The Starr Group Mission is to provide a positive and empowering work environment for our employees and to be a beacon of innovation and integrity to our clients

The Starr Group’s mission statement includes a commitment to the following:

  • Commitment to improve community social needs and practices
  • Care and development of employees
  • Human rights
  • Values, ethics, and integrity
  • Inclusion and diversity

The Starr Group‘s mission applies to all business operations and locations.

The Starr Group has a clearly defined human rights policy regarding the protection of:

  • Minority Groups
  • Women's rights
  • Workers' rights
  • Child labor

 The Starr Group implements their inclusion and diversity commitment in the following ways:

  • Equal opportunity employment policy
  • Prominently displayed inclusive non-discrimination policy in recruitment materials
  • Philanthropic support of groups/charities relating to diverse groups for military and disabled employees

The Starr Group offers the following benefits to single employees, different sex spouses and family/dependents:

  • Health Insurance
  • Dental Insurance
  • Vision Insurance
  • Employee Paid Supplemental Life Insurance
  • Employer Paid Supplemental Life Insurance (single only)
  • Employee Assistance Program (EAP)

Career Development

The Starr Group’s budget and financial statements include a line item for employee training and development and the training program is aligned with company goals.  It supports all employee groups.

Training is focused on employees becoming expert advisers for our customers. Goal is for each producer to be certified (CIC and CRM) within 5 years of employment.

At The Starr Group, managers’ performance is appraised based on their ability to develop their employees.

Each year, The Starr Group plans for 20+ training hours for each employee.

The following training and development programs and amenities are offered to various employee groups:

  • On-line training resources are available
  • Life or career coach (internal or external resource) which is paid in full by the company for supervisory/management and executive employees
  • Life or career coach (internal or external resource) which is subsidized by the company for salaried and hourly employees
  • Participation in professional or trade organizations that is paid in full by the company
  • Employees able to use work hours to participate in professional organization or trade association meetings, committees and events
  • Employees are encouraged to work with external mentors
  • Tuition reimbursement for non-degree granting education programs - CIC and CRM Certification
  • Developmental opportunities for project assignments
  • Career path planning for all employees
  • Succession planning program or strategy for executive employees
  • One-to-one coaching, performance evaluations and/or 360 evaluations.
  • The opportunity to cross train in skills others than those in their current job responsibilities
  • Training to enhance promotability
  • Training to enhance current job skills
  • Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) is one of the most advanced, highly recognized professional education designation programs in the insurance industry. The program provides a comprehensive and continuing education program to individuals who have made a career commitment to insurance.
  • Certified Risk Manager (CRM) is one of the most important designations for risk managers working in the insurance, accounting, finance, and legal fields.

The Starr Group employees have the chance to participate in the following training and development programs:

  • Communication skills
  • Problem solving training
  • Customer service
  • Diversity/Inclusion
  • Harassment
  • Safety
  • Supervisory training for first time managers (supervisory/management and executive employees)
  • Supervisor/management skills (supervisory/management and executive employees)
  • How to orient a new employee (supervisory/management and executive employees)
  • Writing skills
  • Sales/business development
  • Negotiation skills
  • Accounting/finance for non-financial professionals (hourly employees)
  • Performance management plan (supervisory/management and executive employees)
  • Employee performance coaching (supervisory/management and executive employees)
  • Technical skills training
  • Office skills (Microsoft Office, Excel)
  • Culture/employment brand
  • Consumer brand
  • Innovation
  • Time management

In addition the following training and development opportunities are available:

  • The Starr Group's Book Club is available to service and support employees and includes book discussions around: CSR Mastery, Franklin Covey 4DX, The Referral Engine, How Full is your Bucket.
  • Positive Phone Audits based on the competencies related to company values.
  • Employees are encouraged to participate in webinars and conference seminars and share with those who did not participate in the session.
  • Individual department leaders share their competencies with employees during staff meetings 
  • Each new employee receives emails daily for 7 weeks, each week focusing on one of The Starr Groups I-PREACH values.

The Starr Group

Number of Employees
Location Types
Suburban (office park/campus)
Business Founded

Commercial, Group, and Personal Insurance Benefits